
What has been learned during the course of this project is that fire is an
entity which is very difficult to define, and in order to properly model it,
many many variables must be incorporated. To date, no all inclusive fire model
has ever been created. Although many groups such as the U.S. Forest Service
have attempted to accurately model how a fire flows in a forest, no one has
yet created a model which incorporates all the variables that can be observed
in the real world.
Due to the limited time period in which to create this model, the team chose
to model fuel types and wind vectoring because they believed that those two
variables, in particular, affected the flow of fire the most. Although the model
does not take into account many of the variables associated with fire, those
few variables which have been modeled, have created an accurate replication
of how a fire flows n a realistic environment. The variables which have been
incorporated significantly advance the program beyond the progress that was
achieved last year.. Many concepts which were intangible when the project was
first begun have been defined and will be essential in future fire modeling
research. The most important of these is the distinction between fire flow and
heat flow.
The Heat Flow Model
The incorporation of Newton’s Law of Cooling and Fourier’s Law of
Conduction account for convection and conduction, and the introduction of these
two laws into the project gives the project a strong foundation. However, the
radiation model has eluded the modeling process. The Stefan-Boltzmann Law of
Radiation accounts for only fire radiation given off by heat and not the chemical
reaction of fire. Fire’s main method of heat creation is radiation. Therefore,
the heat flow model requires more development, most specifically the radiation
model. The actual fire model is also affected, because if heat cannot be properly
defined, then the effect of temperature upon fire cannot be properly modeled.
The Wind Model
The wind vectoring process makes logical sense. Fire flow can be treated as
a vector of the proportion of the wind speed and its direction and the spread
of the fire across an area. However, this has not been validated yet and can
only remain suspicion.
The Fuel Model
The fuel model generalizes many factors. It breaks the forest and its individual
traits into a square grid with meters as its base unit. This generalization
makes fire flow less accurate. Yet, you cannot model the forest exactly in a
computer program. There are factors that cannot be perfectly defined no matter
how precise you become.
The division of the patches’ fuel into wet and dry fuel also pulls the
fire flow process from the mark. Yet, it is this simplification that gives the
project a basis, flawed, but workable, upon which it can solve the important
part, the fire flow. The program can then easily characterize wet and dry fuels.
The Fire Flow Model
The fire flow process is the biggest success of this project. The Elliptical
Fire Theory gives the program a validated base upon which to build. As more
variables are added to the model, one must know the beneficial or detrimental
effects of the variable upon fire spread to find the growth of the fire. This
is a standard benchmark that depends upon all the incorporated variables the
fire will travel a certain distance at a certain degree.
Variables and Empirical Data
Fire is never exposed to perfect circumstances. In the real world, fire is affected
by many variables, some yet to be defined. This project attempted to take into
account three specific variables that effect fire flow; heat, fuel type, and
wind. However, to determine these variables, other variables must be known,
and eventually integrated. For example, it is known fire spreads at different
rates over different fuels, but it remains unknown exactly at what rate per
fuel type. Empirical data is needed to increase the accuracy of this project.
There are many variables which could become constants with more research and
experimentation.
Though this program may not account for all environmental factors, it does provide
a basis for later addition of these factors when the variables’ effects
are known a can be integrated into the program.
Validation
Looking back, this project has come a long way since last year. The foundation
of the Elliptical Fire Theory has evolved into the modeling of a fire. This
project and the program cannot be disproven, yet cannot be proven at their current
state. This is suggested by the research and data collected.
This program follows basic fire expansion. In a future venture however, further
validation of this project needs more real-world data. This data must then be
collected, compared, and the program adjusted to take into account realistic,
imperfect fire conditions. Possibly a static test could be done to compare the
effects of a real forest fire against the program’s version of the fire.
Or perhaps this program could be compared against FARSITE. The basis of validation
in this project was to validate the Elliptical Fire Theory by burning materials
in relatively perfect conditions. Although in tune with the program, in wildfires
the conditions of the forest are not perfect. For this project to be of any
practical use, the program must be validated against more than perfect conditions.
Overview
This program is the basis upon which a more advanced program can be built. Because
there are so many variables that must be taken into account in order to ensure
a true fire flow program, only a select few have been incorporated as discussed
above. In the future, many more important fire variables must be incorporated
in order to ensure an even more accurate fire flow program. In addition, further
verification will be attempted using actual fire data collected by the United
States Forest Service and other organizations. The team will attempt to verify
that, based on the given environmental conditions, the program would flow in
the same manner and speed evidenced by a past fire. If the program can be validated
by this method using additional variables, then a true to life fire model, which
may be even more accurate than current fire models, could be created for use
in the real world. Fire is a devastating force, and by understanding it, and
using the wondrous technology around us to model and predict it, we may one
day live in a world in which forest fires no longer threaten our homes and our
lives.